During the summer, at the start of the MAC Program, we were encouraged to watch either Freedom Writers or Stand and Deliver. I chose to watch Freedom Writers. It's one of those feel-good, let's save the world films, and I did enjoy (and cried while) watching it. But it also has me thinking about how teachers are portrayed in the media and the great amount of disconnect there is between reality and entertainment.
Just as there are gendered and racial stereotypes, the media loves to pull out a variety of occupational stereotypes. Teachers are often portrayed as overly authoritarian, uncaring, or the cult like figure. Administrators frequently get the negative portrayal too. None of these representations would be truly helpful to students in reality. And female teachers? We're either old-maids or completely inappropriate sex symbols. It is indeed irritating. I would hope the general public sees these portrayals as stereotypes. No matter, many parents and students, still view teachers and schooling in general with an us vs. them mentality.
While Freedom Writers may be touching, there is the troubling issue of the teacher Erin Gruwell. At the end of the film, it is stated that the teacher quit her teaching position after seeing her one class through to graduation. Burn out? Possibly (probably). Ms. Gruwell did an obviously commendable job for reaching out to her students in her unique fashion, but the actions (as portrayed in the movie) are not quite plausible for real teachers. There are very few (almost none certainly) teachers who can throw all their energies into taking care of just one class. Most teachers have multiple classes of 30+ students to guide.
So are these portrayals of 'hero' teachers harmful? I would argue to a certain extent yes. Those teachers who have to balance large class loads and who cannot necessarily take their students on special field trips are no less of a hero than teachers like Erin Gruwell? But the audience of these sorts of teacher-saves-the-day films may certainly have a different viewpoint (of course I was still one of those rooting for Erin's fight against the other 'terrible' teachers).
Being a teacher is not a save everyone or save no one sort of job. Teachers sometimes reach students without even realizing it.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Thanks for this very thoughtful post, Jennifer. I think that your words are wise, and your cautions well-founded. The Erin Gruwells (it was Pete Dixon on the "Room 222" TV show in my day) can help to kindle the spark of inspiration in future teachers, but it isn't a model for a sustained, healthy career, and I agree (I'm also thinking of "Dangerous Minds") about the confused message for young women.
Rich clued me in to the most accurate (warts and all) images of teaching in the mass media I've yet seen--season 4 of "The Wire."
There are good books out there, though. If you need something along these lines to sustain the flame of inspiration over break, I'd suggest Garrett Keizer's "No Place But Here." As an English teacher, I have to think that you would find the story of a small town school teacher to be both quietly inspiring and pleasing from a literary perspective.
Post a Comment